雇主责任保险中“比例赔付条款”的司法定性争议与规制逻辑研究
Research on Judicial Qualification Controversies and Regulatory Logic of the “Proportional Compensation Clause” in Employer’s Liability Insurance
摘要: 雇主责任保险理赔实务中,保险公司普遍将“伤残赔偿比例表”纳入格式合同,直接以法定伤残等级对应固定赔付比例确定赔偿金额,由此引发该条款是否属于《中华人民共和国保险法》第十七条第二款所指免责条款的司法定性争议。当前司法裁判中存在“责任范围约定说”与“实质免责说”的对立,折射出“形式主义”与“功能主义”两种审查范式的冲突。文章赞同“实质大于形式”的功能主义立场,依据最高人民法院《关于适用〈中华人民共和国保险法〉若干问题的解释(二)》第九条规定,主张该类条款实质上减轻了保险人依法应承担的赔偿责任,应属免责条款范畴,保险人须履行提示和明确说明义务,否则条款不生效力。文章进一步提出构建分层级的司法审查逻辑,并探讨《中华人民共和国保险法》第十九条在条款内容控制中的适用空间,以期统一裁判尺度,矫正格式条款导致的利益失衡,实现保险交易实质公平与行业合规发展。
Abstract: In the claims settlement practice of employer’s liability insurance, insurers routinely incorporate “Disability Compensation Ratio Tables” into standard contracts, determining compensation amounts by directly correlating statutory disability grades with fixed payment ratios. This practice has sparked significant judicial controversy regarding whether such clauses constitute “exemption clauses” as defined in Paragraph 2, Article 17 of the Insurance Law. Current judicial decisions reveal a dichotomy between the “Scope of Coverage Agreement Theory” and the “Substantive Exemption Theory”, reflecting a broader conflict between “formalism” and “functionalism” in judicial review paradigms. Aligning with the “substance over form” functionalist approach, this paper argues that pursuant to Article 9 of the “Supreme People’s Court’s Interpretation (II) on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Insurance Law”, such clauses substantively mitigate the insurer’s statutory liability and thus fall within the ambit of exemption clauses. Consequently, insurers bear the obligation to fulfill duties of prominent reminder and explicit clarification; failure to do so renders the clauses invalid. The paper further proposes a hierarchical judicial review framework and explores the applicability of Article 19 of the Insurance Law for content control. These measures aim to harmonize adjudicative standards, rectify imbalances inherent in standard-form contracts, and foster both substantive fairness in insurance transactions and enhanced industry compliance.
参考文献
|
[1]
|
张海双. 罗某诉中国人寿意外伤害保险合同纠纷案中“比例赔付条款”性质研究[D]. 锦州: 渤海大学, 2022.
|
|
[2]
|
李玉泉. 《民法典》与保险人的说明义务[J]. 保险研究, 2020(10): 98-104.
|
|
[3]
|
武亦文. 保险法上约定行为义务违反的法律后果——以保险人免责和解除保险合同为中心[J]. 南大法学, 2022(3): 70-92.
|
|
[4]
|
沈小军. 伤残等级比例给付保险条款的规范控制与责任承担[J]. 中国应用法学, 2024(5): 202-206.
|
|
[5]
|
王静. 保险案件裁判精要[M]. 北京: 法律出版社, 2019.
|
|
[6]
|
最高人民法院民事审判第二庭. 最高人民法院关于保险法司法解释(二)理解与适用[M]. 第2版. 北京: 人民法院出版社, 2015.
|